Texas Court Overturns $100M Nuclear Verdict in Favor of Werner

The Texas Supreme Court has sided with Werner Enterprises, overturning a staggering $100 million jury award linked to a tragic accident from 2014. This incident involved a pickup truck that lost control on an icy interstate and crashed into one of Werner’s trucks traveling in the opposite direction.

Nathan Meisgeier, president and Chief Legal Officer at Werner, expressed relief over the ruling. “This decision is something we’ve awaited for years,” he stated. “After navigating through seven years of appeals, we’re grateful that the Texas Supreme Court aligned with law enforcement’s findings—that our drivers acted responsibly.” He also acknowledged the profound loss experienced by the Blake family due to this accident.

The court’s June 27 ruling clearly stated that all claims against Werner were dismissed and reversed previous judgments made by lower courts.

This case traces back to an intense trial in Houston where jurors delivered what remains one of the highest monetary penalties imposed on a motor carrier. Following this verdict in October 2018, Werner appealed to the Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals but faced setbacks as their appeal was ultimately denied after several years.

During their appeal process, Werner contested both claims of negligence against them and certain evidentiary rulings made during trial proceedings. They also challenged future medical expense awards granted to plaintiffs.

A Major Turnaround for Trucking Industry Standards

“The court found no shared fault on part of our driver,” noted Meisgeier.

The high court emphasized that Shiraz Ali, who was driving for Werner at the time, bore no duty for what transpired when another vehicle skidded across lanes due to icy conditions.

The justices pointed out that Ali was operating his truck within legal limits when suddenly confronted by an out-of-control vehicle crossing into his lane—a situation beyond his control.

“The unfortunate reality is that this incident stemmed from another driver’s loss of control rather than any actions taken by our driver,” they concluded.In its arguments before the high court last August, Werner highlighted critical legal questions regarding liability standards applicable across Texas roadways—especially concerning how drivers should anticipate potential hazards from vehicles on opposing sides.

They contended it would be unreasonable to expect motorists always be prepared for such unpredictable events without being held liable under extreme circumstances.

With its headquarters firmly established among North America’s top logistics providers—ranking No.18 among major carriers—Werner continues advocating for fair treatment within industry regulations while reflecting deeply upon incidents like these.

for more insights or updates related to transportation law or industry standards check out today’s briefing below!